MANAGEMENT vs LEADERSHIP

There is a distinction between management and leadership. Management is about planning, budgeting, and process. Leadership is about vision, strategy, and motivation. There is actually a spectrum between the two and, within modern organisations, individuals are required to move back and forth along the spectrum depending on circumstances and position.

According to Warren Bennis:

A Manager A Leader
  • Administers
  • Is a copy
  • Maintains
  • Focuses on systems & structure
  • Relies on control
  • Has a short-range view
  • Accepts the status quo
  • Innovates
  • Is an original
  • Develops
  • Focuses on people
  • Inspires trust
  • Has a long-range perspective
  • Challenges the status quo

Leadership roles

Senge

Peter Senge poposes that three types of management must work together to create successful change.

Executive leaders (senior management)

  • developing governing ideas
  • designing infrastructure for reward, performance management, learning – an environment to encourage innovation and change
  • teaching and mentoring local line leaders
  • serving as role models

Local Line Leaders (middle and junior management, technical experts)

  • design products and services
  • overcoming obstacles
  • showing commitment & energy at the front line
  • need executive leaders and network leaders

Network leaders (internal or external experts, facilitators)

  • guides, advisors, active helpers, providing insight
  • accesses (resources from elsewhere)
  • work at interfaces between project groups, functions and teams
  • working in partnership with line leaders